Internal · Pre-launch

Reviewer Portal

Review flagged Seerah, Qur’an, Tafsir, Hadith, world-history, miracle, and kids-mode content before public launch.

This portal supports pre-launch review. Reviewer feedback does not constitute a fatwa, endorsement, or final religious ruling.

This portal currently uses local browser storage. Export feedback before clearing browser data. For production, connect reviewer access to Supabase with authentication, roles, and database storage.

Prototype-only: do not collect private personal information. For production reviewer access, add authentication, role-based access, and database-backed storage. Reviewer comments are never exposed in the public learning sections.

Review Queue

42 items

E016· JourneyCritical
Night Journey and Ascension (Isra & Mi’raj)
Theological concernIslamic ScholarHadith / Seerah Reviewer

Highly sensitive theological event; avoid depiction and ensure orthodox framing.

Not started
E023· JourneyCritical
Slander Affair / Hadith Al-Ifk
Theological concernIslamic ScholarHadith / Seerah Reviewer

Sensitive event involving Aisha RA; needs careful wording.

Not started
E030· JourneyCritical
Farewell Pilgrimage, final illness, and passing
Theological concernIslamic ScholarHadith / Seerah Reviewer

Final sermon wording and passing details require precision.

Not started
PB-Lut· Prophets BeforeCritical
Prophet Lut عليه السلام
Kids safetyIslamic ScholarQur’an / Tafsir Reviewer

Sensitive content; flagged for kids-mode safety and Isra’iliyyat.

Not started
PB-Isa· Prophets BeforeCritical
Prophet Isa عليه السلام
Theological concernIslamic ScholarQur’an / Tafsir Reviewer

Theological precision required; avoid Christian-framing.

Not started
MIR003· Miracles & SignsCritical
Zamzam water — Abrahamic sign connected to Hajar, Ismail عليه السلام, Makkah, and Hajj. Not a miracle performed by Prophet Muhammad ﷺ.
Theological concernIslamic ScholarHadith / Seerah Reviewer

Pre-prophetic Abrahamic sign; must not be framed as a miracle of the Prophet ﷺ.

Not started
E006· JourneyMajor
Interruption and return of revelation
Theological concernIslamic ScholarHadith / Seerah Reviewer

Fatrah al-Wahy framing requires careful theological wording.

Not started
E009· JourneyMajor
Quraysh opposition and attempts to stop the message
Factual errorIslamic ScholarHadith / Seerah Reviewer

Multiple Seerah narrations; ensure accuracy and sourcing.

Not started
E010· JourneyMajor
Persecution of early Muslims
Kids safetyIslamic ScholarHadith / Seerah Reviewer

Sensitive content; needs kids-mode safety review.

Not started
E021· JourneyMajor
Battle of Badr
Factual errorIslamic ScholarHadith / Seerah Reviewer

Numbers, names, and angelic support require careful sourcing.

Not started
E022· JourneyMajor
Battle of Uhud
Factual errorIslamic ScholarHadith / Seerah Reviewer

Casualty figures and event sequence vary across sources.

Not started
PB-Ibrahim· Prophets BeforeMajor
Prophet Ibrahim عليه السلام
Isra’iliyyatIslamic ScholarQur’an / Tafsir Reviewer

Some narrations carry Isra’iliyyat risk.

Not started
PB-Yusuf· Prophets BeforeMajor
Prophet Yusuf عليه السلام
Kids safetyIslamic ScholarQur’an / Tafsir ReviewerParent / Teacher Reviewer

Story contains sensitive elements requiring kids-safe wording.

Not started
PB-Dawud· Prophets BeforeMajor
Prophet Dawud عليه السلام
Isra’iliyyatIslamic ScholarQur’an / Tafsir Reviewer

Common Isra’iliyyat narrations must be excluded.

Not started
MIR006· Miracles & SignsMajor
Splitting of the moon
Claim-riskIslamic ScholarHadith / Seerah Reviewer

NASA-photo narration must stay inside SourceDrawer only.

Not started
MIR014· Miracles & SignsMajor
Naming hypocrites to Hudhayfah RA
Theological concernIslamic ScholarHadith / Seerah Reviewer

Sensitive; ensure sensitivity note remains inside SourceDrawer.

Not started
MIR015· Miracles & SignsMajor
Qur’an as permanent living miracle
Theological concernIslamic ScholarQur’an / Tafsir Reviewer

Theological framing of i’jaz al-Qur’an must be precise.

Not started
DUA001· Du’asMajor
Du’a record DUA001
Grading inaccuracyHadith / Seerah ReviewerIslamic Scholar

Verify hadith grading, source citation, and Arabic wording.

Not started
DUA002· Du’asMajor
Du’a record DUA002
Grading inaccuracyHadith / Seerah ReviewerIslamic Scholar

Verify hadith grading, source citation, and Arabic wording.

Not started
DUA003· Du’asMajor
Du’a record DUA003
Grading inaccuracyHadith / Seerah ReviewerIslamic Scholar

Verify hadith grading, source citation, and Arabic wording.

Not started
DUA004· Du’asMajor
Du’a record DUA004
Grading inaccuracyHadith / Seerah ReviewerIslamic Scholar

Verify hadith grading, source citation, and Arabic wording.

Not started
DUA005· Du’asMajor
Du’a record DUA005
Grading inaccuracyHadith / Seerah ReviewerIslamic Scholar

Verify hadith grading, source citation, and Arabic wording.

Not started
DUA006· Du’asMajor
Du’a record DUA006
Grading inaccuracyHadith / Seerah ReviewerIslamic Scholar

Verify hadith grading, source citation, and Arabic wording.

Not started
DUA007· Du’asMajor
Du’a record DUA007
Grading inaccuracyHadith / Seerah ReviewerIslamic Scholar

Verify hadith grading, source citation, and Arabic wording.

Not started
DUA008· Du’asMajor
Du’a record DUA008
Grading inaccuracyHadith / Seerah ReviewerIslamic Scholar

Verify hadith grading, source citation, and Arabic wording.

Not started
DUA009· Du’asMajor
Du’a record DUA009
Grading inaccuracyHadith / Seerah ReviewerIslamic Scholar

Verify hadith grading, source citation, and Arabic wording.

Not started
DUA010· Du’asMajor
Du’a record DUA010
Grading inaccuracyHadith / Seerah ReviewerIslamic Scholar

Verify hadith grading, source citation, and Arabic wording.

Not started
C009· CompanionsMajor
Bilal RA — kids summary
Kids safetyParent / Teacher ReviewerIslamic Scholar

Persecution content must be age-appropriate.

Not started
C007· CompanionsMajor
Fatimah RA — kids summary
Kids safetyParent / Teacher ReviewerIslamic Scholar

Sensitive content about the Prophet’s family ﷺ.

Not started
W-614· WorldMajor
Jerusalem and Surah Ar-Rum context (614 CE)
Historian reviewWorld History ReviewerAdminQur’an / Tafsir Reviewer

Connection between Surah Ar-Rum and Byzantine–Sassanid wars needs scholarly + historian check.

Not started
E027· JourneyMajor
Battle of Khaybar
Factual errorIslamic ScholarHadith / Seerah Reviewer

Confirm event sequence, treaty terms, and hadith citations.

Not started
MIR011· Miracles & SignsMajor
Khubayb RA healing narration
Grading inaccuracyIslamic ScholarHadith / Seerah ReviewerParent / Teacher Reviewer

Verify hadith grading and kids-safe wording.

Not started
W-572· WorldMajor
Byzantine–Sassanid framing (c. 572 CE)
Historian reviewWorld History ReviewerAdmin

Pre-Seerah world framing requires academic historian verification.

Not started
W-628· WorldMajor
Khosrow II and Persia framing (628 CE)
Historian reviewWorld History ReviewerAdmin

Confirm event sequence and political framing.

Not started
W-636· WorldMajor
Yarmouk and post-Seerah conquest framing (636 CE)
Claim-riskWorld History ReviewerAdmin

Sensitive conquest framing; verify tone and accuracy.

Not started
E012· JourneyMinor
Conversion of Hamzah and Umar RA
Factual errorIslamic ScholarHadith / Seerah Reviewer

Popular narrations vary; verify Seerah sources.

Not started
C010· CompanionsMinor
Mus’ab ibn Umayr RA — kids summary
Kids safetyParent / Teacher ReviewerIslamic Scholar

Verify kids-mode tone.

Not started
MIR010· Miracles & SignsMinor
MIR010 — kids summary
Kids safetyParent / Teacher ReviewerIslamic Scholar

Verify kids wording for miracle record.

Not started
TES008· Voices Across TimeMinor
Non-Muslim testimony TES008
Missing sourceUX / Content ReviewerWorld History ReviewerAdmin

Verify citation book/page details.

Not started
TES009· Voices Across TimeMinor
Non-Muslim testimony TES009
Missing sourceUX / Content ReviewerWorld History ReviewerAdmin

Verify citation book/page details.

Not started
TES010· Voices Across TimeMinor
Non-Muslim testimony TES010
Missing sourceUX / Content ReviewerWorld History ReviewerAdmin

Verify citation book/page details.

Not started
TES011· Voices Across TimeMinor
Non-Muslim testimony TES011
Missing sourceUX / Content ReviewerWorld History ReviewerAdmin

Verify citation book/page details.

Not started

Review Tracker

0 saved reviews
RecordSectionReviewerIssueSeverityCommentDecisionStatusBlocksTime
No reviews yet.

For production, connect this to Supabase with reviewer login, role-based access, and database-backed storage.